I’m trying to figure out what tags to map to the various RPG Bloggers’ Planet’s categories. I used a little Perl script to extract and count the categories people used for their blog posts. As you can see, there doesn’t seem to be a lot of common tags in the last 100 entries:
1 , 1 10th Doctor 1 3e 1 40k 1 AP 1 About e 1 Adventure Hook 1 Adventure-Prep 1 Arcana 1 Ask the GMs 1 At-The-Table 1 Beginners 1 Behind-The-Screen 1 Board 1 Board Games 1 Bureau 13 1 Call of Cthulhu 1 Campaign Creation 1 Campaign Management 1 Campaign Notes 1 Campaign-Admin 1 Campaign-Setting 1 Character creation 1 Class Discussions 1 Collateral 1 Critical hit 1 Cthulhu 1 D&D 4e 1 D&D Blog 1 D&D/Pathfinder 1 DM 1 DM Advice 1 DM Resources 1 DM tools 1 DM-Advice 1 Design 1 Design Diary 1 DnD 1 Dr Who 1 Dragon Magazine 1 Dungeon Master Resource 1 Dungeon Mastering Techniques 1 Electronic Games 1 Elements of Design 1 Encounters 1 Equipment 1 Essen 1 Events 1 Fantasy 1 Fantasy Craft 1 Fast Food and Snack Foods 1 Featured 1 Funny Games 1 Game News 1 Game design 1 Game mechanic 1 Game-Mastery 1 Gamer Life 1 Gameroom 1 Games 1 Games & Hobbies 1 Games Workshop 1 Gaming 1 Geek Life 1 Geek Stuff 1 General Musings 1 Google Wave 1 H. P. Lovecraft 1 Hex map 1 Hippy Game 1 Hobbies 1 Hobby 1 Homebrew 1 Houserules 1 Humour 1 Ideas & Inspiration 1 InSpectres 1 Incidents Involving Me 1 Inspiration 1 Johnn 1 K9 1 Legal Villainy 1 Lich 1 Lisbon 1 Lords of Tyr Podcast 1 Lovecraft 1 Map 1 Maps 1 Meta 1 Mike 1 Miniatures 1 Monster 1 Monsters 1 Necromancer 1 News / Reviews / Culture 1 Non-RPG 1 ODnD 1 Opinion 1 Other 1 Other Games 1 PC 1 PCs 1 Paizo 1 Philosophy 1 Planescape: Torment 1 Planning & Preparation 1 Plausibility 1 Players 1 Playtesting 1 Politics 1 Portugal 1 Prep 1 RPG tools 1 RPGBlog 1 Read through 1 Robin Hood 1 Robin Laws 1 Role-Playing 1 Role-playing game 1 Roleplaying 1 Roleplaying Games 1 Rom 1 SJA 1 Scenario-Creation 1 Science Fiction & Fantasy 1 Settings 1 Skill Challenge 1 Skill Challenges 1 Space Marine 1 Spain 1 Spirits Of Eden 1 Sports 1 Star Trek 1 Swords and Wizardry general 1 TV 1 Tabletop Games 1 Teerna 1 Television 1 Thundarr 1 TnT 1 Travel and Tourism 1 Treasure 1 Tumblelog 1 Ultimate Sandbox 1 Uncategorized 1 Undead 1 Urban 1 Video 1 Villains 1 Warhammer 40k 1 Warhammer Fantasy 1 Weekend Rants 1 Wizards of the Coast 1 World Design 1 accents 1 actual play 1 adventure ideas 1 advice 1 alpha omega 1 army 1 astrology 1 bemci 1 bestiary 1 blogging 1 book 1 buffy 1 call of cthulhu 1 campaign log 1 campaigns 1 character 1 clothing 1 d and d 1 d20 1 dating 1 dating profile help 1 discussion 1 dnd classic 1 dvd 1 eberron 1 elemental 1 fluff/inspiration 1 foxy friday 1 freshen up 1 frontpage 1 game 1 game analysis 1 gamer life 1 geek dating 1 geek matchmaking 1 geekdom 1 google wave 1 houserules 1 land of 2 rivers 1 links 1 magic items 1 megan fox 1 miniatures 1 miscellaneous 1 modern, 1 monsters 1 moria 1 old school 1 phylactery 1 play 1 playtest 1 podcasting 1 potluck 1 preview 1 random 1 random tables 1 rant 1 red flags 1 religion 1 review 1 rituals 1 role-playing, 1 rpg, 1 rpgs 1 sci-fi genre 1 setting design 1 skill checks 1 soapbox 1 swords and wizardry 1 tabletop 1 tunnels and trolls 1 vampire 1 vampirella week 1 virgin DM 1 warhammer 1 writing 1 zombie apocalypse 1 zombie attack 1 zombies 2 4E 2 Adventures 2 Card Games 2 Classic Board Games 2 Comics 2 Culture 2 Emerald City Game Feast 2 Essay 2 Game Mastering 2 Gamemastering 2 Geek Love 2 Humor 2 Menagerie 2 Mutant Future 2 NPCs 2 News 2 News, Reviews & Culture 2 Nick 2 Other Systems 2 Pathfinder 2 Play 2 Player Resources 2 Review 2 Stuff 2 babe 2 board game 2 campaign 2 dnd 2 games 2 halloween 2 item 2 online dating 2 plugging 2 rpg 2 tv 3 Advice/Tools 3 Campaigns 3 Dungeon's Master 3 Fluff/Inspiration 3 Legacy DnD 3 Modern Board Games 3 Podcasts 3 RPG Hub 3 horror 4 Advice 4 Dungeons and Dragons 4 Game Design 4 RPGs 5 Dungeons & Dragons 6 D&D 8 4e 10 RPG
I’m a bit at a loss, here. I’m no longer convinced this is a good system of categorizing blog posts! I guess most people will use tags to differentiate particular posts from the rest of their own posts. That’s why I never use tags such as “D&D” or “3e” – because that’s the default I’m assuming, I guess. But that’s no longer true when looking at my blog posts in comparison with everbody else. Many of them ought to be tagged “D&D” and “3e”.
Clearly, I underestimated the problem of translating tags into categories!
|4e||4e, D&D 4e|
|Old School||old school, becmi (even though the tag used was “bemci”), swords and wizardry, Swords and Wizardry general (?), Mutant Future, TnT, Thundarr, tunnels and trolls, ODnD|
|Advice||any tag containing “Advice”, Ask the GMs, advice, Game Mastering, Gamemastering, Campaign Management|
|Review||any tag containing “Review”,|
Any other ideas out there?
I usually skip the discussions on blogs. Sometimes I’ll read the handful of comments already there before adding my own. I usually subscribe to email notifications and that’s that. Interesting discussions are rare, however.
Recently I’ve found two:
- The Problem With 'Old School'... – lots of suggestions to prevent the four total party kills in three sessions the original poster reported
- What kind of campaign style and mood do you enjoy the most? – lots of opinions showing the wide variety of campaign styles out there
I’ve written a post about my preferred campaign style yesterday, I’ve written about various my DM profile, and at the last con I was, I talked to other people about play styles. As you can tell from my previous posts, I’m very interested in all sorts of typification. But I never considered the session mood.
At that last con, I was surprised. See, I recently joined a Rolemaster group where the game master is really laid back. When we meet on Saturdays, there’s talk about new harddrives, the prices of ink cardriges, what food to cook, when to eat, stuff we did – where as I’m used to after work games. 3½ hours is all we have! So go, go, go!
I remember at one point they were talking on and on, and I started preparing for my Monday D&D game instead of wasting time. I was disappointed!
But at this last con I mentioned, I met people who just liked to get into character. They told me that when they game, it’s all candle light, medieval music, fresh fruit served in pewter dishes, traditional saussages, and talking in character. The mind boggled.
So now I’m curious. I want to see how other people slow down, relax, and play. No action, just flow. We’ll see whether that works for me. I don’t want to be a one trick pony!
I wrote a little Perl script that parses Apache log files and counts referrers. It’s pretty specific for this site, since it tries to determine for both site and referrer whether the log entry is about Emacs Wiki, my blog, Oddmuse, etc.
The numbers for my blog in yesterday’s 24h period: 75307, which is 5% of the total number of hits in the log file. Of these, 50276 hits had no referrer information, 13196 came from my own site.
Now, to understand this, one needs to understand that most of the traffic on the web is caused by search engines. At least for my site!
aschroeder@thinkmo:~$ egrep 'GET /(cgi-bin/)?alex' logs/access.log.1 | wc -l 75308 aschroeder@thinkmo:~$ egrep 'GET /(cgi-bin/)?alex.*google' logs/access.log.1 | wc -l 18202
Fully 24% of all my traffic is Google related!
But now, some numbers: I still have 75307-50276-13196=11835 hits to explain!
- rpgbloggers.com: 5962 – RPG Bloggers results in a lot of hits. That’s pretty amazing. Not many people comment. Either my articles are so perfect (haha), or so full of it (although that has never stopped trolls from commenting elsewhere), or just plain not interesting. I guess I rarely hit the mainstream when it comes to RPG blogging.
- emacswiki.org: 2329 – Emacs Wiki remains my best known project and has a lot of visitors. As a link to my homepage can be found on my profile, I guess that’s how they find it. But I haven’t checked this.
- google: 888 – various Google sites from all over the world. I’m surprised that so many people find me via Google. I’ll have to check whehter these entries are from the Google Bot or from actual people. If so, I’d also learn something about the queries used to find the blog.
- odd74.proboards.com: 567 – this must be based on the small number of messages I posted on the Fight On Forum.
- communitywiki.org: 467 – Community Wiki is a dormant project of mine. Still a lot of referrals!
- jrients.blogspot.com: 147 – Jeff Rients’ blog? I left a few comments there, and it is in fact a very cool blog. I didn’t know that so many people clicked through to my blog. Here, too, it would be worth while trying to figure out whether there is one comment in particular that’s at the source of this.
- chattydm.net: 122 – Chatty DM is a blog that I rarely comment on. I guess the reason for the current referrals is my participation in the One Page Dungeon Contest 2009; strictly speaking that would be yet another hypothesis to test, however.
- tiddlywiki.com: 134 – I haven’t used TiddlyWiki in ages, but years ago I wrote a little hypertext dream using it. I think it got linked from the main site, so that would explain the big number.
- poietic-aggregator.com: 63 – I think the Poietic Aggregator is a project by some wiki people. It’s a weird RSS visualizer. I never got the hang of it.
- orientalisch.info: 60 – Claudia’s website. I’m surprised that so many people click through. This must be something else. I should investigate this.
- blo.gs: 59 – I’m not sure whether I’m still pinging the site. Right now the site seems to be inbetween owners. Always a bad sign. I wonder how they manage to refer to my blog anyway.
- finch.ploogy.net: 54 – the first real surprise. A website that “makes slow Internet bearable, by stripping away the fat of web pages, leaving just the content. It takes out CSS, images, flash, metadata, iframes and more, meaning less for your computer to load.” What a cool idea. I hope that Finch doesn’t really find much stuff to strip from my web pages. When I check them with YSlow I get an A grade for everything but “use a content delivery network” (not big enough) and “compress components with gzip” (I thought about this but this requires me to know the size of the content before serving headers, and I prefer to server as quickly as possible).
- campaignwiki.org: 52 – not many people are using Campaign Wiki, a project of mine offering a very simple wiki without ads for gamers.
- bloglines.com: 44 – a blog aggregator like google reader. Interesting.
- wandersite.ch: 39 – a hike or two of mine are linked from that site.
- rsp-blogs.de: 35 – the German version of rpgbloggers.com!
- bing.com: 35 – search engine
- oddmuse: 23 – another software project of mine
- bitethebulette.blogspot.com: 22 – a enw blog that I’ve discovered recently
And many other small hits.
Yesterday I decided to try the switch from BlogLines to GoogleReader, again. I find the interface quite confusing. I expected my subscriptions to be at the center of things, bit as I keep using the site I find that the items my “friends” are sharing dominating my reading experience. I did not find an easy way to exclude them. Even if there is a way, I am astonished at how hard it is to find. I also note how tricky unsubscribing seems to be. I apparently I need to do that in my settings. I’ll try for a while longer, but for now I wonder whether the Gmail user interface engineer would do the same. Or if it is the same guy, what his thoughts were. I don’t doubt that the Reader is a software masterwork with all the asynchronous stuff going on. But the user interface takes some getting used to. Plus: I use the mobile interface for Gmail and Google Reader in addition to the usual web interface. Both need to be useful.
I’m happy with my RPG Planet. I don’t use it much, since I’ve subscribed to all these blogs via BlogLines, too. But it might turn out to be an interesting resource for people just getting into the entire blog reading experience. It’s a sort of filtered RPG Bloggers.
I am, however, still struggling with XSLT. Not because I don’t understand how it works, or how XPath works – but because I don’t really get to see the intermediary format that the style sheet is acting on. I will have to investigate the cache directory some more.
Right now, for example, the subscription list has links containing a title attribute. That title attribute doesn’t refer to the linked blog, however, but to the planet’s title (and is therefore the same for all blogs). That needs to be fixed.
The guys from RPG Bloggers seem to have some site issues   In the first post talking about it, Dave says they’ll “probably have to accept advertising” in order to develop some code. I mentioned I’d rather have fewer features and less ads and pointed to Planet Emacsen which runs Planet Venus, but apparently “it’s a matter of needing custom code to handle the specific demands of the network”. Oh well.
Just to figure out how difficult it would be to setup up Planet Venus I spent some time investigating it. One of my sites is hosted by HCoop which uses the Andrew File System. I lost quite some time trying to figure out why my planet was not being published until I found a workaround leading to http://planet.campaignwiki.org filled with some sample blogs. After all, it’s just a proof of concept.
Ok, I’m also procrastinating because I ought to be translating Labyrinth Lord from English to German.
Anyway, so now I have convinced myself that I could do it. I also like how Planet Venus lets me produce custom output using XSLT and other stuff I have used very rarely.
Here are some things I’m thinking about:
- Should I just use my own preferences when choosing the feeds? After all, as long as RPG Bloggers is working just fine there’s no need for me set up a similar service. As you can tell from the sample blogs, I prefer that old school vibe.
- In a similar vein, assuming I keep building on it: The current code doesn’t categorize posts. Such a thing would be interesting to add, but to be honest, I never use the various categories provided by RPG Bloggers (and my own category tags don’t seem to work).
- I would like to have a public source for feeds – a wiki page or something similar. Anybody should be able add or remove blogs from the list. I miss Grognardia on RPG Bloggers, for example.
- Alternatively, we could use a list of OPML files and automatically generate a planet based on the reading lists of a smaller number of people.
- I’m not sure what sort of load issues the existing RPG Bloggers network is running into. Should I just try adding tons of blogs to my RPG Planet and see how load develops?
Looking at my BlogLines account, I see this:
- Gaming (1667)
- Regularly (1084)
- Occasionally (596)
- Rarely (289)
- Eventually (250)
I started by reading one or two blogs with only one or two new posts. I’m not ready to start diving right in. Perhaps I should try to expunge some of those blogs. I cannot remember the last time I read anything in the rarely and eventually categories, for example.
Here’s how I deal with it: The network allows me to “sample” tons of blogs. I skim the front page and maybe the second page every now and then, looking for new stuff. If I like something, I will subscribe the the individual feed. The network works for me since I use it to discover new blogs by skimming the front page. I don’t try to real all the articles on it.
That’s also why I don’t want a “quality” filter for these blogs. I’m happy the “featured” articles got moved out of the way. I don’t need them. I do appreciate the lack of product announcement and the focus on the personal. I care both about long and thoughtful posts as well as short and funny posts. I want to learn more about our hobby, but I also want to learn more about the people playing it. That’s why I am subscribed to some blogs that also features short and single paragraph posts. I don’t mind.
In fact, I prefer succinct posts to rambling.
Which is why I need to stop.
Some blogs I’m enjoying at the moment:
- Grognardia by James Maliszewski
- Sham’s Grog ’n Blog by David Bowman
- The Alexandrian by Justin Alexander
- hack/ by Mike Hensley
- Jeff’s Gameblog by Jeff Rients
- Von der Seifenkiste herab by Moritz Mehlem (in German)
- Uhluht’c Awakens by Dan Proctor
stands for “I’ve read the entire blog archive.” (Or nearly all of it.) That usually just works for one year of blogging.