2011-12-16 SOPA and NDAA

Copyright is killing music

@3liza: #NDAA and #SOPA both passed. And it didn’t matter how we voted, who we phoned, what petitions we signed, which websites we made.

I’m happy not to be living in the USA. The sad thing is that the USA doesn’t just export “intellectual property” in the form of music, it also exports the legal framework to install this market abroad. Sooner or later a lot of people around the world have to fight their local battles to prevent the same kind of idiocy from happening in their own countries.

The Stop Online Piracy Act is terrible. I’ve been following BoingBoing on SOPA for a while. Check TechDirt on the SOPA amendments for some dispairingly inane Congress. Way to go! Where’s Lawrence Lessig and his Rootstrikers movement?

What I find particularly disappointing is that these days, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act is being held up as a model even though its “anti-circumvention” provisions are also terrible (EFF on DMCA). Soon after it was introduced, Switzerland revised its copyright law. We are still allowed to download stuff for personal use (”Eigengebrauch”). The government recently confirmed this. That means that if I have something that is “protected” by DRM, I am still allowed to make a copy for myself. To exercise my right, I need to circumvent the restrictions placed on the thing I want to copy. It turns out that thanks to the USA’s export of legal frameworks, the Swiss copyright law now also has an anti-circumvention article (Art. 39a Schutz technischer Massnahmen). Thus, while I am allowed to circumvent DRM in order to exercise my legal rights, others are prohibited from “creating, importing, offering, selling, distributing, renting, letting, advertizing or owning with the intent to profit” the very tools that I need to exercise my legal rights.

SOPA will lead to the same levels of inanity, I’m sure. Just google for DNS alternatives.

As for the rest... For obvious reasons I don’t care whether the National Defense Authorization Act affects US citizens or not. At least they get to taste some of what they are serving the rest of the world. It’s just like the Transportation Security Administration and how they make life miserable for everybody without actually helping much (BoingBoing on TSA). People like me just start avoiding the USA.

Oh, and while I’m thinking of the USA – let us remember Iraq and the nearly 4500 Americans killed, the 32000 Americans injured [1] and the more than 150000 Iraqis killed.



Clinton (8 years):

  1. Somalia
  2. Iraq
  3. Yugoslavia/Bosnia/Serbia
  4. Haiti
  5. Albania
  6. Sudan
  7. Afghanistan
  8. Iraq
  9. DMCA
  10. Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act
  11. Colombia

Bush Junior (8 years):

  1. Afghanistan
  2. USAPA
  3. Guantanamo
  4. Philippines
  5. Iraq
  6. Yemen
  7. Haiti
  8. Somalia
  9. Syria

Obama (4 years):

  1. Camp Guantanamo
  2. Iraq for 3 years
  3. Afghanistan
  4. UN diplomatic spying
  5. Pakistan
  6. Assassination of Bin Laden
  7. Yemen
  8. Stuxnet
  9. Libya
  10. SOPA

The USA is usually worse under a Democratic Party executive. I believe this is because there is fewer opposition by citizens.

AaronHawley 2011-12-19 02:14 UTC


AlexSchroeder 2011-12-20 07:46 UTC

Please make sure you contribute only your own work, or work licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. Note: in order to facilitate peer review and fight vandalism, we will store your IP number for a number of days. See Privacy for more information. See Info for text formatting rules. You can edit the comment page if you need to fix typos. You can subscribe to new comments by email without leaving a comment.

To save this page you must answer this question:

Please say HELLO.