2020-12-17 Halberds and Helmets Saving Throws

sent a follow up mail with some thoughts on H&H saving throws. Looking at the stats in the cheat sheet, he made this table:

save vs. death             5 
save vs. dragon breath     8 
save vs. explosions        1 
save vs. paralysis         5 
save vs. poison           15 
save vs. rays              2 
save vs. spells           16 

I guess explosions are something I use for non-monsters, like grenades. The one reference in the cheat sheet is the ice devil casting ice storm and you “save vs. explosions” for half damage. It just looks better in my mind’s eye than using “save vs. dragon breath”.

Well, J. Alan Henning has a different proposal: to streamline them slightly!

He reclassifies them:

save vs. death             5 → save vs. death ray 
save vs. dragon breath     8   
save vs. explosions        1 → save vs. death ray 
save vs. paralysis         5   
save vs. poison           15   
save vs. rays              2 → save vs. death ray 
save vs. spells           16   

Is the ice devil’s storm more like a death ray? I don’t know! I’m feeling like I should be shouting: “Noooooo! This changes everything!” But the truth is, of course, that this is exactly what people should do. 😁

save vs. death ray         8 
save vs. dragon breath     8 
save vs. paralysis         5 
save vs. poison           15 
save vs. spells           16 

In an effort to write super concise rules mashing up H&H and the Target 20 variant from Searchers of the Unknown he ends up with this for saving throws: “roll a d20, add their level, and add the modifier as shown below; roll 20 or higher to succeed.”

spells                    +1
dragon breath             +2 
paralysis                 +3
death ray                 +4
poison                    +5

An interesting choice! Poison is the harshest, dragon breath is not so bad. Or not? Of course, it’s the reverse: a higher bonus makes it more likely to make the target number, so poison is the least dangerous where as spells are the most dangerous. All right! Well, only playtesting can show whether it works – and I suspect players simply adjust their risk behaviour to compensate for any perceived changes. If at all! I know that as a player I hardly ever think too much about the details of the rules.

Comments


Please make sure you contribute only your own work, or work licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. Note: in order to facilitate peer review and fight vandalism, we will store your IP number for a number of days. See Privacy Policy for more information. See Info for text formatting rules. You can edit the comment page if you need to fix typos. You can subscribe to new comments by email without leaving a comment.

To save this page you must answer this question:

Just say HELLO